Project 2025 Tracker
Checked

Related development. Not a Project 2025 recommendation.

Federalizing National Guard troops for city deployments over governors' objections

BlockedDocumented actionLitigation pending

The Supreme Court left a block on the Chicago deployment in place in December 2025; lower courts ruled similarly for Los Angeles and Portland.

Last changed Last checked
Report an error

What was proposed, said or done

  • In October 2025 the President federalized Illinois National Guard troops and sent Guard forces to the Chicago area over Gov. JB Pritzker's objection.[1]

What has happened

  • On December 23, 2025, the Supreme Court declined to let the Chicago deployment proceed, saying the government had not identified authority allowing the military to execute the laws in Illinois. Justices Alito, Thomas and Gorsuch dissented.[1]
  • Lower and appellate courts also ruled against deployments over governors' objections in Los Angeles and Portland.[1]

What is in effect now

  • The ruling is preliminary and covers only deployments over a governor's objection; deployments a governor requests, such as Louisiana's, are not affected.[1]

Legal constraints

  • The statute used turns on whether the President is unable to execute federal law with the "regular forces"; the Court read that phrase as referring to the military, which favored Illinois.[1]
  • Guard forces under federal control remain subject to the Posse Comitatus Act, which generally bars the military from policing.[2]

Why it matters

  • AnalysisThese cases turn on who controls a state's Guard, the governor or the President, and on how far soldiers can be used for police work.

Uncertainty and disputed points

  • The Court's order did not address the Insurrection Act.[1]

Status history

DateStatusNote
Dec. 23, 2025BlockedSupreme Court leaves block in place. (Litigation pending)
Oct. 4, 2025UnderwayFederalization announced for Illinois.

Blocked: Action was taken but a court order currently prevents all or a significant part of it from operating. Definitions

Sources

  1. [1]Supreme Court sides with Chicago over Trump in dispute over Guard Roll Call, Dec. 23, 2025. Accessed Nov. 17, 2026.
  2. [2]Trump threatened to invoke the Insurrection Act (again). What is it? NPR via MPR News, Jan. 15, 2026. Accessed Nov. 17, 2026.